Role by Post vs Myth-Weavers — A Modern Play-by-Post Alternative
Myth-Weavers is one of the best-known names in online tabletop gaming. It is especially loved for its character sheets and its play-by-post forums, and it has served the community for years. If you want a classic forum board plus a widely used sheet tool, it does that well.
Role by Post approaches play-by-post from the other direction: a chat-first campaign app built for asynchronous play on a phone. Here is how the two compare.
The format
Both support asynchronous, written play. Myth-Weavers keeps the familiar forum thread structure, where a game is organized into posts and replies on a board. That structure is powerful for archiving long games and for browsing a game's history.
Role by Post presents the same play as a single timeline: one flowing story per campaign, with scene breaks, quoted replies, and reactions that stay attached to their post. The goal is a conversation that reads back like fiction, on a small screen.
Character sheets
This is where Myth-Weavers is strongest — its sheet builder is a big part of why people use it. Role by Post is not a sheet platform. It keeps per-channel character names, avatars, and character notes, and lets each player pin a character sheet URL so their sheet stays one tap away. Each campaign gets its own character name (up to 20 characters), its own portrait, and its own sheet link, so one account can play a different character in every game without a second profile. If a built-in interactive sheet is essential to your game, Myth-Weavers has the deeper tool; if you already keep sheets elsewhere, a pinned link may be all you need.
Rooms and side conversations
Play-by-post produces more than one kind of conversation: the story, the dice, the rules question, the aside. Role by Post keeps them apart with rooms — Main plus up to ten extra conversations inside the campaign — so the story timeline stays readable prose while the table talk has somewhere to go. Each room keeps its own status bar and its own unread dot, and the GM can make a room private to the players they invite or to themselves, or turn dice and NPC posts off in a room that should stay narrative. How rooms work
Notes that live with the campaign
Sheets are not the only notes a game accumulates. Role by Post keeps three notebooks per campaign: Character Notes (yours and the Game Master's), Party Notes (everyone's), and GM Notes (the GM's alone). They live with the campaign, are shared across every room, and update live, so nobody has to hunt through a forum thread or a separate document for the party's plan. Campaign notes
Game tools and alerts
Role by Post builds the table's tools into the conversation:
- A native dice roller — tap notation to roll, open an ability check with the modifier pre-filled, and roll pools or success dice.
- NPCs with names and portraits in the timeline.
- A persistent status bar for initiative, active players, and notes.
- Safety tools — lines and veils plus an anonymous X-card — inside each channel.
- Unread counts and per-channel push notifications, including a "your turn" option.
- Full-text search and a Markdown export of the campaign.
Mobile and feel
Role by Post is mobile-first and installable, so it behaves like a native app on a phone. Myth-Weavers is a traditional web application, which is fine on desktop but denser on mobile.
The short version
| Myth-Weavers | Role by Post | |
|---|---|---|
| Style | Forum play-by-post | Chat-first timeline |
| Character sheets | Built-in, best in class | Pinned link + name, avatar, notes |
| Character per campaign | Sheet per character | Name, portrait, and sheet link per game |
| Rooms | Forum boards | Up to 10 rooms per campaign, private rooms |
| Campaign notes | Sheets and forum threads | Character, party, and GM notebooks |
| Mobile experience | Traditional web UI | Mobile-first, installable app |
| Dice | Built in | Built in, with ability checks and pools |
| Turn alerts | Manual | Per-channel push, including "your turn" |
| Safety tools | Community norms | Built into the channel |
| Cost | Free | Free |
The bottom line
If a built-in character sheet is the center of your game, Myth-Weavers remains a strong choice. If you want a modern, chat-like, mobile-first place to play asynchronously — with rooms, campaign notes, dice, NPCs, safety tools, and turn alerts built in — Role by Post is designed for exactly that. It is free and ready in minutes. Start with what play-by-post is.